The Talk
‘Pag ba ako‘ng naunang
Maglahad ng palad, at
Lumapit nang marahan,
Magtataka ka ba?
‘Di man ako halata,
Nagtitimping mag-isa,
Dinadaan na lang sa tula—
Tanong sa tadhana
If I made the first move
By holding out my hand, and
Moving gently closer,
Would you wonder why?
Even if it isn't obvious,
I'm holding back on my own,
Using poetry just to cope—
And questioning destiny.
—Na Para Bang by Mariah Deborah
Stop lying. Everyone knows what the talk is. No one is exempt from the friendzone. Sure, you’re a queen bee or an alpha chad, but the world is complicated, and even if you’re in, you’re not always inside. What is it like inside, like inside-inside? You know that scene when you’re staring into her eyes and it’s her face that’s doing all the talking? I would say that when you’re there, you should see the betrayal of the innermost feelings outside, extrinsically presented to you through her exterior form. In short, there is no inside when you’re inside.
The late, great Alfonso Ossorio said, “In my end is my beginning.” That motto was taken from Mary, Queen of Scots—En ma fin gît mon commencement. As I walked through his works at the Metropolitan Museum of Manila recently, I was reminded of the day I spent admiring the Angry Christ mural inside the Victorias Milling compound a few years ago. I was also reminded of my interaction with Toots Manahan on a separate occasion where she recounted to me how she was researching how to restore said church mural. Alfonso’s life and legacy have had a profound effect on how I approach art-making these days. I am still obsessed with the idea that Jackson Pollock might have been remembered very differently had Alfonso not been an early supporter, both as a patron and a friend, of the tortured painter.
When you see bulging plastic eyes, shattered reflective surfaces, and heavy disjointed pieces of wood compressed onto one surface, you’re left to wonder about the calcifications that led to the choice of using such jarring materials. Alfonso was open about his struggle with queer identity alongside his Catholic upbringing. When you see the Angry Christ in person, there’s a certain lightness to it—or maybe that’s just me. I’m connecting this observation to Mariah’s song almost haphazardly, but it’s related to the non-feeling of true understanding. I can see the same strong red lines on the mural that most people equate to anger, hence its publicly given name, but not register the anger because I think it is already distributed across my whole being.
Modern life is divorced from evolutionary reality. However, societal systems have tried to preserve a semblance of that long lineage of biological information being passed down through generations. I’m walking on a tightrope here, but hear me out. The feeling of genital pleasure—for both XX and XY—is not sacred. Why use an implicit after-death punishment or reward for that matter to discourage accepting that it feels good? It feels good because nature wants to reward the act of reproduction. We are not that smart, but we were smart enough to separate sexual pleasure from the replication of genetic information.
I like poetry. I like how poetry can be so easily misinterpreted. The gaps of thought between ideas depend heavily on the pictures in the reader’s head. Those gaps are not unique to the medium, and that’s why the adjective poetic exists. Charting the unknown feelings as we suddenly realize that someone can be more than a friend is poetic. The imagined conversation by you, the tortured sailor navigating the romantic seas, with the vessel of your desire when you confess your bottled-up interest is poetic. The most difficult part of poetry is knowing that the unsaid is what actually unlocks the door inside. When someone tells you you’re cute, don’t tell them they’re cute back. Tell them not to fall in love with your cuteness. The gap that will create in their head is one hell of a poetic hook, possibly award-winning.
Why am I so insistent about minding the gaps? Because I once created enough gaps for a girl—intrinsically XY—to flirt with me to the point where I—intrinsically and extrinsically XY—got a little too excited, and to my surprise, enjoyed it. Let’s just say all I had to do was walk through the open door. Now, this is where I get dark because there are some lines that I prefer not to cross, lest I become a slave to pleasure itself. I am already enslaved enough as it is. The mere sight of Mariah on a flat screen makes me swoon even though it will likely stay unrequited for now. I wish she featured a version of me in the recent Na Para Bang music video who could part the Red Sea like Moses. I blame the Wish 107.5 Bus for installing these feelings, but at least I’m not ashamed to lay it out in the open.
Your musical phrasing is to die for, Mariah. The rise and fall of those silent passages is poetic. My heart is dancing to the varied staccatos of the unsaid. The gap I will create with you now is to declare my undying love for silence. Without the silences, musicality might cease to exist. And by loving them, I am saying that they matter more than the words you sang in Tagalog, but not more than what I feel when I hear your voice. Don’t hold back on your own—we can all hold back together to create more flicking silences that produce beautiful music.
One of my most important discoveries in life was to stop listening to preachers. Why forbid the replication of beautiful mistakes? Without knowledge of what is wrong, we would never be here in the first place. It’s like telling a surfer to freeze up and not be a slave to the tides. You can never fly if you don’t jump. I hate it when people tell me to do or not to do x without a properly constructed argument. We don’t need to be right—we just need to fulfill our own destinies.